The County and Judge Can Impact the Outcome of Your Case

Scott Scherr • June 24, 2026

The County and Judge Can Have a Major Impact on Your Case.

If you are charged with a crime or receive a traffic citation, the location of the offense can greatly influence the outcome of the case. Under Maryland law, the case must be brought in the county in which the offense was committed. In fact, I have successfully gotten cases thrown out where the charge was brought in the wrong county.


Judges differ in how they approach cases, decide guilt and innocence, and handle sentencing. Prosecutors also are more willing to give you a better deal in some counties as opposed to others. This means that someone charged with a DUI in one county may face a much harsher penalty than someone charged with a DUI in another. In a few counties, a judge will make probation unsupervised and in other counties supervision will be required and it will be lengthy.


In each county, different judges have unique tendencies. Someone with a second DUI may go to jail with certain judges and receive probation before judgment (if the first one is more than 10 years old) with others. It is important to know the reputation of the judges, prosecutors, and even police officers.


If the offense carries more than 90 days in jail, there is a right to a jury trial. This can be used as a way to get the matter out of the hands of a harsh judge. If the conviction or sentence is unjust in the District Court, you can also file an appeal to the Circuit Court within 30 days and have a new trial.


There are also special circumstances that create greater risk for an individual. Someone who is not a citizen could be deported or lose a chance to become a citizen depending on the outcome of the case. A commercial driver's license holder could face a lengthy suspension and lose his or her job. A conviction for a DUI can lead to a license suspension or revocation. A conviction for violating a license restriction can also lead to a license suspension.


Sometimes it is crucial to take steps to show the court you have learned your lesson by doing an alcohol treatment program, PADDD, a drug program, a driver improvement program, an anti-theft case, community service, volunteer work, or other activities. This can make the difference between going to jail or going home with certain judges. This becomes more important in certain counties and with certain judges.


You may find that things are different and the consequences more dire in more rural parts of the State. It is important to speak with an attorney to determine the tendencies of the courts in the county where your case is pending as well as the tendencies of your judge.

By Scott Scherr June 16, 2026
You can likely avoid a reckless driving by paying a related speeding ticket. Should you do it?
By Scott Scherr May 18, 2026
Almost all criminal and traffic stops have bodycam video.
By Scott Scherr May 7, 2026
Several new laws will take effect on October 1, 2026.
By Scott Scherr April 22, 2026
If you received a traffic ticket for an accident, you may be able to win your case.
By Scott Scherr April 7, 2026
Police are issuing tickets for reckless driving for speeding 30 mph over the speed limit and you could go to jail.
By Scott Scherr March 17, 2026
Make sure you obtain this crucial information after an automobile accident.
By Scott Scherr February 27, 2026
There are ways to prevent a license suspension.
By Scott Scherr February 13, 2026
A stet can be a good outcome in a criminal case.
By Scott Scherr February 4, 2026
Courts consider many factors in deciding whether to set bail.
By Scott Scherr January 30, 2026
The Legislature Has Increased Points Assessed for Some Traffic Violations