Miranda

Scott Scherr • September 22, 2023

Your rights under Miranda and what they mean

We also have heard the Miranda warning:


"You have the right to remain silent."


"Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law."


"You have the right to an attorney."


"If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be provided to you."


The police officer will then ask you if you want to speak and waive your right to remain silent.


Most people are under several misimpressions about the application of Miranda. The police officer does not have to read you your rights if they wish to interrogate you unless you are in police custody. Many times, you are not in police custody when the police officer questions you. If you are stopped for speeding and the officer asks how much you had to drink, he does not need to read you your rights. You are not yet in police custody. If you fail the field sobriety tests and are arrested, you are then in police custody.


There are many cases where the police fail to Mirandize the Defendant when they should. Many people think this will result in a dismissal of all charges. Unfortunately, this is not the case.


The failure to read you your rights while in police custody will result in all subsequent statements by you deemed inadmissible at trial. In addition, all "fruit of the poisonous tree" is also inadmissible. This means any information the police learn from the improper interview which led to other evidence is tainted and inadmissible. However, the police can still convict you using other evidence obtained through other lawful means.


For example, if you are arrested for a DUI, handcuffed, and taken to the station, any admissions you make at the station may be inadmissible if they failed to read you your rights. However, you can still be convicted from other evidence such as odor of alcohol, swaying, poor field sobriety tests, and a breathalyzer result over the legal limit.


You should always remember that you do not have to give a statement to the police regardless of whether your rights are read. You should always tread carefully because anything you say "can and will be used against you in a court of law."


By Scott Scherr • October 7, 2026
It is illegal to drive with an open container in Maryland.
By Scott Scherr • September 23, 2026
Judges are sending people to jail. You should be proactive to maintain your freedom.
By Scott Scherr • September 17, 2026
New Laws Are Coming Soon
By Scott Scherr • August 27, 2026
Artificial Intelligence Can Be Useful, But It is Often Flawed
By Scott Scherr • July 27, 2026
The MVA Will Soon Start Fining Maryland Residents With Out of State Tags
By Scott Scherr • July 17, 2026
A Motion to Suppress Can Keep Out "Fruit of the Poisonous Tree."
By Scott Scherr • June 24, 2026
The County and Judge Can Have a Major Impact on Your Case.
By Scott Scherr • June 16, 2026
You can likely avoid a reckless driving by paying a related speeding ticket. Should you do it?
By Scott Scherr • May 18, 2026
Almost all criminal and traffic stops have bodycam video.
By Scott Scherr • May 7, 2026
Several new laws will take effect on October 1, 2026.