Right to a Jury Trial

Scott Scherr • November 21, 2025

You have a constitutional right to a jury trial in these cases.

You have a right to a jury trial in criminal and civil cases in certain circumstances. Not every case allows you to have a trial in front of a jury.


You have a jury trial in a criminal case where one of the charges carries more than 90 days in jail as a maximum penalty. Therefore, you do not have a right to a jury trial if you receive a speeding ticket since it is a non-incarcerable offense. Similarly, there is a no right to a jury trial if the sole charge is driving without a license for a first offense since that carries a maximum penalty of 60 days in jail.


All jury trials in criminal cases take place before 12 men and women from the motor-voter rolls of the county where the case is tried. The verdict must be unanimous. If the jury cannot agree, it will result in a hung jury and the case can be tried again.


In civil cases, there is a right to a jury trial if the claim for damages exceeds $25,000.00. Therefore, a small claims court case is always tried in front of a judge. If you want to avoid a jury trial, limit your claim to $25,000.00 or less.


Civil jury trials take place before six men and women from the motor voter rolls of the county in which the case is tried. The verdict must be unanimous and a hung jury will result in a retrial.


There are circumstances where you may like your chances better before a jury as opposed to a judge or vice versa. In a criminal case, it is the Defenant's choice. However in a civil case, either side can request a jury trial.

By Scott Scherr • September 23, 2026
Judges are sending people to jail. You should be proactive to maintain your freedom.
By Scott Scherr • September 17, 2026
New Laws Are Coming Soon
By Scott Scherr • August 27, 2026
Artificial Intelligence Can Be Useful, But It is Often Flawed
By Scott Scherr • July 27, 2026
The MVA Will Soon Start Fining Maryland Residents With Out of State Tags
By Scott Scherr • July 17, 2026
A Motion to Suppress Can Keep Out "Fruit of the Poisonous Tree."
By Scott Scherr • June 24, 2026
The County and Judge Can Have a Major Impact on Your Case.
By Scott Scherr • June 16, 2026
You can likely avoid a reckless driving by paying a related speeding ticket. Should you do it?
By Scott Scherr • May 18, 2026
Almost all criminal and traffic stops have bodycam video.
By Scott Scherr • May 7, 2026
Several new laws will take effect on October 1, 2026.
By Scott Scherr • April 22, 2026
If you received a traffic ticket for an accident, you may be able to win your case.