Right to a Jury Trial

Scott Scherr • November 21, 2025

You have a constitutional right to a jury trial in these cases.

You have a right to a jury trial in criminal and civil cases in certain circumstances. Not every case allows you to have a trial in front of a jury.


You have a jury trial in a criminal case where one of the charges carries more than 90 days in jail as a maximum penalty. Therefore, you do not have a right to a jury trial if you receive a speeding ticket since it is a non-incarcerable offense. Similarly, there is a no right to a jury trial if the sole charge is driving without a license for a first offense since that carries a maximum penalty of 60 days in jail.


All jury trials in criminal cases take place before 12 men and women from the motor-voter rolls of the county where the case is tried. The verdict must be unanimous. If the jury cannot agree, it will result in a hung jury and the case can be tried again.


In civil cases, there is a right to a jury trial if the claim for damages exceeds $25,000.00. Therefore, a small claims court case is always tried in front of a judge. If you want to avoid a jury trial, limit your claim to $25,000.00 or less.


Civil jury trials take place before six men and women from the motor voter rolls of the county in which the case is tried. The verdict must be unanimous and a hung jury will result in a retrial.


There are circumstances where you may like your chances better before a jury as opposed to a judge or vice versa. In a criminal case, it is the Defenant's choice. However in a civil case, either side can request a jury trial.

By Scott Scherr November 3, 2025
If you think it is a scam, it probably is.
By Scott Scherr October 15, 2025
Buddy's Law Increases Limit on Pet Injuries to $25,000
By Scott Scherr September 29, 2025
Speed camera tickets will be a lot more costly.
By Scott Scherr September 23, 2025
There are ways to determine if you have an outstanding warrant.
By Scott Scherr September 11, 2025
Requesting a waiver hearing is a mistake in traffic cases.
By Scott Scherr September 4, 2025
Everyone should periodically look themselves up on Case Search.
By Scott Scherr July 29, 2025
The disposition in your criminal or traffic case can have unforeseen consequences.
By Scott Scherr July 1, 2025
There are new taxes effective July 1, 2025.
By Scott Scherr June 19, 2025
A new Maryland law will make reckless driving and some speeding tickets incarcerable.
By Scott Scherr June 17, 2025
The law imposes certain obligations on you if you are in an accident.